Consistency of impact assessment protocols for non-native species
Autori
González-Moreno, PabloLazzaro, Lorenzo
Vila, Montserrat
Preda, Cristina
Adriaens, Tim
Bacher, Sven
Brundu, Giuseppe
Copp, Gordon
Essl, Franz
García-Berthou, Emili
Katsanevakis, Stelios
Moen, Toril Loennechen
Lucy, Frances
Nentwig, Wolfgang
Roy, Helen
Srėbalienė, Greta
Talgø, Venche
Vanderhoeven, Sonia
Anđelković, Ana
Arbačiauskas, Kęstutis
Auger-Rozenberg, Marie-Anne
Bae, Mi Jung
Bariche, Michel
Boets, Pieter
Boieiro, Mário
Borges, Paulo Alexandre
Canning-Clode, João
Cardigos, Federico
Chartosia, Niki
Cottier-Cook, Elizabeth Joanne
Crocetta, Fabio
D'hondt, Bram
Foggi, Bruno
Follak, Swen
Gallardo, Belinda
Gammelmo, Øivind
Giakoumi, Sylvaine
Giuliani, Claudia
Guillaume, Fried
Jelaska, Lucija Šerić
Jeschke, Jonathan
Jover, Miguel
Juárez-Escario, Alejandro
Kalogirou, Stefanos
Kočić, Aleksandra
Kytinou, Eleni
Laverty, Ciaran
Lozano, Vanessa
Maceda-Veiga, Alberto
Marchante, Elizabete
Marchante, Hélia
Martinou, Angeliki
Meyer, Sandro
Minchin, Dan
Montero-Castano, Ana
Morais, Maria Cristina
Morales-Rodriguez, Carmen
Muhthassim, Naida
Nagy, Zoltán
Ogris, Nikica
Onen, Huseyin
Pergl, Jan
Puntila, Riikka
Rabitsch, Wolfgang
Ramburn, Triya Tessa
Rego, Carla
Reichenbach, Fabian
Romeralo, Carmen
Saul, Wolf-Christian
Schrader, Gritta
Sheehan, Rory
Simonović, Predrag
Skolka, Marius
Soares, António Onofre
Sundheim, Leif
Tarkan, Ali Serhan
Tomov, Rumen
Tricario, Elena
Tsiamis, Konstantinos
Uludağ, Ahmet
van Valkenburg, Johan
Verreycken, Hugo
Vettraino, Anna Maria
Vilar, Lluis
Wiig, Øystein
Witzell, Johanna
Zanetta, Andrea
Kenis, Marc
Članak u časopisu (Objavljena verzija)
Metapodaci
Prikaz svih podataka o dokumentuApstrakt
Standardized tools are needed to identify and prioritize the most harmful non-native species (NNS). A plethora of assessment protocols have been developed to evaluate the current and potential impacts of non-native species, but consistency among them has received limited attention. To estimate the consistency across impact assessment protocols, 89 specialists in biological invasions used 11 protocols to screen 57 NNS (2614 assessments). We tested if the consistency in the impact scoring across assessors, quantified as the coefficient of variation (CV), was dependent on the characteristics of the protocol, the taxonomic group and the expertise of the assessor. Mean CV across assessors was 40%, with a maximum of 223%. CV was lower for protocols with a low number of score levels, which demanded high levels of expertise, and when the assessors had greater expertise on the assessed species. The similarity among protocols with respect to the final scores was higher when the protocols conside...red the same impact types. We conclude that all protocols led to considerable inconsistency among assessors. In order to improve consistency, we highlight the importance of selecting assessors with high expertise, providing clear guidelines and adequate training but also deriving final decisions collaboratively by consensus.
Ključne reči:
Environmental impact / expert judgement / invasive alien species policy / management prioritization / risk assessment / socio-economic impactIzvor:
Neobiota, 2019, 44, 1-25Izdavač:
- Pensoft
Finansiranje / projekti:
- Evolucija u heterogenim sredinama: mehanizmi adaptacija, biomonitoring i konzervacija biodiverziteta (RS-MESTD-Basic Research (BR or ON)-173025)
- COST Action TD1209
- CABI Development Fund
- Darwin plus, DPLUS074
- Belmont Forum-Biodiversa project InvasiBES (PCI2018-092939)
- Sciex-NMSch 12.108
- BiodivERsA (FFII project; DFG grant JE 288/7-1)
- DFG project JE 288/9-1,9-2
- Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia grants SFRH/BPD/91357/2012 and SFRH/BPD/86215/2012 RVO 67985939 and 17-19025S
- 2014 FCT Investigator Programme (IF/01606/2014/CP1230/CT0001)
Institucija/grupa
IZBISTY - JOUR AU - González-Moreno, Pablo AU - Lazzaro, Lorenzo AU - Vila, Montserrat AU - Preda, Cristina AU - Adriaens, Tim AU - Bacher, Sven AU - Brundu, Giuseppe AU - Copp, Gordon AU - Essl, Franz AU - García-Berthou, Emili AU - Katsanevakis, Stelios AU - Moen, Toril Loennechen AU - Lucy, Frances AU - Nentwig, Wolfgang AU - Roy, Helen AU - Srėbalienė, Greta AU - Talgø, Venche AU - Vanderhoeven, Sonia AU - Anđelković, Ana AU - Arbačiauskas, Kęstutis AU - Auger-Rozenberg, Marie-Anne AU - Bae, Mi Jung AU - Bariche, Michel AU - Boets, Pieter AU - Boieiro, Mário AU - Borges, Paulo Alexandre AU - Canning-Clode, João AU - Cardigos, Federico AU - Chartosia, Niki AU - Cottier-Cook, Elizabeth Joanne AU - Crocetta, Fabio AU - D'hondt, Bram AU - Foggi, Bruno AU - Follak, Swen AU - Gallardo, Belinda AU - Gammelmo, Øivind AU - Giakoumi, Sylvaine AU - Giuliani, Claudia AU - Guillaume, Fried AU - Jelaska, Lucija Šerić AU - Jeschke, Jonathan AU - Jover, Miguel AU - Juárez-Escario, Alejandro AU - Kalogirou, Stefanos AU - Kočić, Aleksandra AU - Kytinou, Eleni AU - Laverty, Ciaran AU - Lozano, Vanessa AU - Maceda-Veiga, Alberto AU - Marchante, Elizabete AU - Marchante, Hélia AU - Martinou, Angeliki AU - Meyer, Sandro AU - Minchin, Dan AU - Montero-Castano, Ana AU - Morais, Maria Cristina AU - Morales-Rodriguez, Carmen AU - Muhthassim, Naida AU - Nagy, Zoltán AU - Ogris, Nikica AU - Onen, Huseyin AU - Pergl, Jan AU - Puntila, Riikka AU - Rabitsch, Wolfgang AU - Ramburn, Triya Tessa AU - Rego, Carla AU - Reichenbach, Fabian AU - Romeralo, Carmen AU - Saul, Wolf-Christian AU - Schrader, Gritta AU - Sheehan, Rory AU - Simonović, Predrag AU - Skolka, Marius AU - Soares, António Onofre AU - Sundheim, Leif AU - Tarkan, Ali Serhan AU - Tomov, Rumen AU - Tricario, Elena AU - Tsiamis, Konstantinos AU - Uludağ, Ahmet AU - van Valkenburg, Johan AU - Verreycken, Hugo AU - Vettraino, Anna Maria AU - Vilar, Lluis AU - Wiig, Øystein AU - Witzell, Johanna AU - Zanetta, Andrea AU - Kenis, Marc PY - 2019 UR - https://plantarum.izbis.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/965 AB - Standardized tools are needed to identify and prioritize the most harmful non-native species (NNS). A plethora of assessment protocols have been developed to evaluate the current and potential impacts of non-native species, but consistency among them has received limited attention. To estimate the consistency across impact assessment protocols, 89 specialists in biological invasions used 11 protocols to screen 57 NNS (2614 assessments). We tested if the consistency in the impact scoring across assessors, quantified as the coefficient of variation (CV), was dependent on the characteristics of the protocol, the taxonomic group and the expertise of the assessor. Mean CV across assessors was 40%, with a maximum of 223%. CV was lower for protocols with a low number of score levels, which demanded high levels of expertise, and when the assessors had greater expertise on the assessed species. The similarity among protocols with respect to the final scores was higher when the protocols considered the same impact types. We conclude that all protocols led to considerable inconsistency among assessors. In order to improve consistency, we highlight the importance of selecting assessors with high expertise, providing clear guidelines and adequate training but also deriving final decisions collaboratively by consensus. PB - Pensoft T2 - Neobiota T1 - Consistency of impact assessment protocols for non-native species EP - 25 SP - 1 VL - 44 DO - 10.3897/neobiota.44.31650 ER -
@article{ author = "González-Moreno, Pablo and Lazzaro, Lorenzo and Vila, Montserrat and Preda, Cristina and Adriaens, Tim and Bacher, Sven and Brundu, Giuseppe and Copp, Gordon and Essl, Franz and García-Berthou, Emili and Katsanevakis, Stelios and Moen, Toril Loennechen and Lucy, Frances and Nentwig, Wolfgang and Roy, Helen and Srėbalienė, Greta and Talgø, Venche and Vanderhoeven, Sonia and Anđelković, Ana and Arbačiauskas, Kęstutis and Auger-Rozenberg, Marie-Anne and Bae, Mi Jung and Bariche, Michel and Boets, Pieter and Boieiro, Mário and Borges, Paulo Alexandre and Canning-Clode, João and Cardigos, Federico and Chartosia, Niki and Cottier-Cook, Elizabeth Joanne and Crocetta, Fabio and D'hondt, Bram and Foggi, Bruno and Follak, Swen and Gallardo, Belinda and Gammelmo, Øivind and Giakoumi, Sylvaine and Giuliani, Claudia and Guillaume, Fried and Jelaska, Lucija Šerić and Jeschke, Jonathan and Jover, Miguel and Juárez-Escario, Alejandro and Kalogirou, Stefanos and Kočić, Aleksandra and Kytinou, Eleni and Laverty, Ciaran and Lozano, Vanessa and Maceda-Veiga, Alberto and Marchante, Elizabete and Marchante, Hélia and Martinou, Angeliki and Meyer, Sandro and Minchin, Dan and Montero-Castano, Ana and Morais, Maria Cristina and Morales-Rodriguez, Carmen and Muhthassim, Naida and Nagy, Zoltán and Ogris, Nikica and Onen, Huseyin and Pergl, Jan and Puntila, Riikka and Rabitsch, Wolfgang and Ramburn, Triya Tessa and Rego, Carla and Reichenbach, Fabian and Romeralo, Carmen and Saul, Wolf-Christian and Schrader, Gritta and Sheehan, Rory and Simonović, Predrag and Skolka, Marius and Soares, António Onofre and Sundheim, Leif and Tarkan, Ali Serhan and Tomov, Rumen and Tricario, Elena and Tsiamis, Konstantinos and Uludağ, Ahmet and van Valkenburg, Johan and Verreycken, Hugo and Vettraino, Anna Maria and Vilar, Lluis and Wiig, Øystein and Witzell, Johanna and Zanetta, Andrea and Kenis, Marc", year = "2019", abstract = "Standardized tools are needed to identify and prioritize the most harmful non-native species (NNS). A plethora of assessment protocols have been developed to evaluate the current and potential impacts of non-native species, but consistency among them has received limited attention. To estimate the consistency across impact assessment protocols, 89 specialists in biological invasions used 11 protocols to screen 57 NNS (2614 assessments). We tested if the consistency in the impact scoring across assessors, quantified as the coefficient of variation (CV), was dependent on the characteristics of the protocol, the taxonomic group and the expertise of the assessor. Mean CV across assessors was 40%, with a maximum of 223%. CV was lower for protocols with a low number of score levels, which demanded high levels of expertise, and when the assessors had greater expertise on the assessed species. The similarity among protocols with respect to the final scores was higher when the protocols considered the same impact types. We conclude that all protocols led to considerable inconsistency among assessors. In order to improve consistency, we highlight the importance of selecting assessors with high expertise, providing clear guidelines and adequate training but also deriving final decisions collaboratively by consensus.", publisher = "Pensoft", journal = "Neobiota", title = "Consistency of impact assessment protocols for non-native species", pages = "25-1", volume = "44", doi = "10.3897/neobiota.44.31650" }
González-Moreno, P., Lazzaro, L., Vila, M., Preda, C., Adriaens, T., Bacher, S., Brundu, G., Copp, G., Essl, F., García-Berthou, E., Katsanevakis, S., Moen, T. L., Lucy, F., Nentwig, W., Roy, H., Srėbalienė, G., Talgø, V., Vanderhoeven, S., Anđelković, A., Arbačiauskas, K., Auger-Rozenberg, M., Bae, M. J., Bariche, M., Boets, P., Boieiro, M., Borges, P. A., Canning-Clode, J., Cardigos, F., Chartosia, N., Cottier-Cook, E. J., Crocetta, F., D'hondt, B., Foggi, B., Follak, S., Gallardo, B., Gammelmo, Ø., Giakoumi, S., Giuliani, C., Guillaume, F., Jelaska, L. Š., Jeschke, J., Jover, M., Juárez-Escario, A., Kalogirou, S., Kočić, A., Kytinou, E., Laverty, C., Lozano, V., Maceda-Veiga, A., Marchante, E., Marchante, H., Martinou, A., Meyer, S., Minchin, D., Montero-Castano, A., Morais, M. C., Morales-Rodriguez, C., Muhthassim, N., Nagy, Z., Ogris, N., Onen, H., Pergl, J., Puntila, R., Rabitsch, W., Ramburn, T. T., Rego, C., Reichenbach, F., Romeralo, C., Saul, W., Schrader, G., Sheehan, R., Simonović, P., Skolka, M., Soares, A. O., Sundheim, L., Tarkan, A. S., Tomov, R., Tricario, E., Tsiamis, K., Uludağ, A., van Valkenburg, J., Verreycken, H., Vettraino, A. M., Vilar, L., Wiig, Ø., Witzell, J., Zanetta, A.,& Kenis, M.. (2019). Consistency of impact assessment protocols for non-native species. in Neobiota Pensoft., 44, 1-25. https://doi.org/10.3897/neobiota.44.31650
González-Moreno P, Lazzaro L, Vila M, Preda C, Adriaens T, Bacher S, Brundu G, Copp G, Essl F, García-Berthou E, Katsanevakis S, Moen TL, Lucy F, Nentwig W, Roy H, Srėbalienė G, Talgø V, Vanderhoeven S, Anđelković A, Arbačiauskas K, Auger-Rozenberg M, Bae MJ, Bariche M, Boets P, Boieiro M, Borges PA, Canning-Clode J, Cardigos F, Chartosia N, Cottier-Cook EJ, Crocetta F, D'hondt B, Foggi B, Follak S, Gallardo B, Gammelmo Ø, Giakoumi S, Giuliani C, Guillaume F, Jelaska LŠ, Jeschke J, Jover M, Juárez-Escario A, Kalogirou S, Kočić A, Kytinou E, Laverty C, Lozano V, Maceda-Veiga A, Marchante E, Marchante H, Martinou A, Meyer S, Minchin D, Montero-Castano A, Morais MC, Morales-Rodriguez C, Muhthassim N, Nagy Z, Ogris N, Onen H, Pergl J, Puntila R, Rabitsch W, Ramburn TT, Rego C, Reichenbach F, Romeralo C, Saul W, Schrader G, Sheehan R, Simonović P, Skolka M, Soares AO, Sundheim L, Tarkan AS, Tomov R, Tricario E, Tsiamis K, Uludağ A, van Valkenburg J, Verreycken H, Vettraino AM, Vilar L, Wiig Ø, Witzell J, Zanetta A, Kenis M. Consistency of impact assessment protocols for non-native species. in Neobiota. 2019;44:1-25. doi:10.3897/neobiota.44.31650 .
González-Moreno, Pablo, Lazzaro, Lorenzo, Vila, Montserrat, Preda, Cristina, Adriaens, Tim, Bacher, Sven, Brundu, Giuseppe, Copp, Gordon, Essl, Franz, García-Berthou, Emili, Katsanevakis, Stelios, Moen, Toril Loennechen, Lucy, Frances, Nentwig, Wolfgang, Roy, Helen, Srėbalienė, Greta, Talgø, Venche, Vanderhoeven, Sonia, Anđelković, Ana, Arbačiauskas, Kęstutis, Auger-Rozenberg, Marie-Anne, Bae, Mi Jung, Bariche, Michel, Boets, Pieter, Boieiro, Mário, Borges, Paulo Alexandre, Canning-Clode, João, Cardigos, Federico, Chartosia, Niki, Cottier-Cook, Elizabeth Joanne, Crocetta, Fabio, D'hondt, Bram, Foggi, Bruno, Follak, Swen, Gallardo, Belinda, Gammelmo, Øivind, Giakoumi, Sylvaine, Giuliani, Claudia, Guillaume, Fried, Jelaska, Lucija Šerić, Jeschke, Jonathan, Jover, Miguel, Juárez-Escario, Alejandro, Kalogirou, Stefanos, Kočić, Aleksandra, Kytinou, Eleni, Laverty, Ciaran, Lozano, Vanessa, Maceda-Veiga, Alberto, Marchante, Elizabete, Marchante, Hélia, Martinou, Angeliki, Meyer, Sandro, Minchin, Dan, Montero-Castano, Ana, Morais, Maria Cristina, Morales-Rodriguez, Carmen, Muhthassim, Naida, Nagy, Zoltán, Ogris, Nikica, Onen, Huseyin, Pergl, Jan, Puntila, Riikka, Rabitsch, Wolfgang, Ramburn, Triya Tessa, Rego, Carla, Reichenbach, Fabian, Romeralo, Carmen, Saul, Wolf-Christian, Schrader, Gritta, Sheehan, Rory, Simonović, Predrag, Skolka, Marius, Soares, António Onofre, Sundheim, Leif, Tarkan, Ali Serhan, Tomov, Rumen, Tricario, Elena, Tsiamis, Konstantinos, Uludağ, Ahmet, van Valkenburg, Johan, Verreycken, Hugo, Vettraino, Anna Maria, Vilar, Lluis, Wiig, Øystein, Witzell, Johanna, Zanetta, Andrea, Kenis, Marc, "Consistency of impact assessment protocols for non-native species" in Neobiota, 44 (2019):1-25, https://doi.org/10.3897/neobiota.44.31650 . .